Character Owners Get About 5.4% of Retail Price
We counted all 196 players on the character map. 77 of the 92 IP owners carry a licensing royalty tag, and only 11 carry a direct merch tag alone. This piece asks why about 5.4% of retail turns into high margins.
Character Owners Get About 5.4% of Retail Price
about 4 min
How much of the money spent on character merchandise reaches the character's owner? And if that share is small, why have Disney, Sanrio and Pinkfong moved toward making less themselves? This piece follows those questions through a map of 196 players across the US, Europe, Korea, Japan and China. Research is as of October 13, 2026.
This time we did not pick standout cases. We counted the whole map by role, revenue tag, key metric and trend, and three things came out. Of the 92 IP owners and studios, 77 carry the "Licensing Royalties" tag, and only 11 carry "Direct Merch" alone. Of the 25 players that are declining or exited or sold, 11 are IP owners and studios. And 15 of the 17 indie creators and artists have a scale tier of "?".
5.4% and 9% measure the same share in different ways
- Measured against retail, it is about 5.4% (△). That figure divides total royalties by total retail sales, and it comes from 2016 and 2018 data. Contract royalty rates average about 9% of wholesale, and character properties run higher at 10.24% (2019 survey, △).
- The gap comes from the denominator. The map's pricing structure runs from COGS to wholesale at about 2–2.5x, then to retail at about 2x (◇). Royalties are typically levied on wholesale, which works out to about 4–5% of retail, not far from 5.4%. Saying owners get 9% and saying they get 5.4% do not contradict each other.
- That is why sales and company revenue sit on different scales. Third parties sold $773M in licensed Moomin goods (#41 on License Global), while the company's own revenue was about €19M. Disney shows the same pattern at $63.0B against $4.45B in booked consumer products revenue.
Small revenue does not mean small profit
- Margins look high on the licensing side. Disney Consumer Products has an operating margin of about 49%, Sanrio about 40%, Toei Animation's licensing business 55%, and Moomin an operating margin of about 61% (2023, reported). This reads as the result of licensees carrying the inventory and the factories. The map describes this revenue stream as "Zero inventory · Highest profit margins."
- Pop Mart reaches a similar place by the opposite road. It licenses nothing out, makes artist IP itself and sells it directly, with a gross margin of 72.1% and artist and IP costs of about 2.2% of revenue. But 72.1% should not be set straight against Disney's 49%. On the same operating-margin basis Pop Mart is about 45%, and the Disney figure covers the consumer products segment only.
Count the whole map and most owners license out
- 77 of the 92 IP owners collect royalties. 49 carry only the "Licensing Royalties" tag, 28 carry it together with "Direct Merch," and 11 carry "Direct Merch" alone. Most owners stand on the licensing side rather than making goods themselves.
- Makers lean the other way. Of the 31 manufacturers and licensees, 30 carry "Direct Merch," 14 carry "Blind Box & Collectibles," and 8 carry "Licensing Royalties." Holding inventory is mostly this side's job.
- Key metrics are mixed. Among the 92 IP owners, the key metric is company revenue for 44, licensed retail sales for 10 and unverified for 27. What others sold and what a company booked sit in the same table, so tiers alone are hard to compare.
Each region picks a different road
- Europe leans toward licensing. Of 39 European players, 22 carry only "Licensing Royalties," and 8 carry only "Direct Merch."
- China leans toward selling directly. Of 34 Chinese players, 17 carry only "Direct Merch," and 11 carry "Blind Box & Collectibles." Only 5 carry royalties alone.
- Japan runs both. Of 46 Japanese players, 16 carry both tags, and 30 are "Growing." Among 40 Korean players, 19 are "Flat," more than the 16 that are "Growing."
What direct sellers take on
- Inventory. The map describes direct merchandise as a model that "earns like licensing at peak hype, left holding inventory when trends fade." Funko wrote off $30M in inventory, and its 2025 revenue was −13.5% with a net loss of $67.4M. Pinkfong took losses on in-house merchandise after its 2019 revenue peak and moved to a partner model.
- Concentration. Labubu's share of Pop Mart revenue came down from 38% to 26% in H1 2026. On share alone that looks like diversification, but in H1 2026 company revenue was +23.8% while THE MONSTERS was −7.5%. Other products grew while the sales of one series actually shrank.
- Margins vary widely even among licensed-in players. Gross margin is 32.1% at TOP TOY (2025, △), 46.8% at Blokees (布鲁可, 2025) and 67.3% at Kayou (2024, △), against 72.1% at Pop Mart, which sells its own IP. Companies using others' IP differ by more than twofold among themselves. On operating margin, Kotobukiya, which makes its own goods, is at 4.6%. The map also records Chinese players pivoting toward "proprietary IP" in 2025–26.
The 17 indie creators start with blank numbers
- Key metrics are followers or unverified. Of the 17 indie creators and artists, 8 use followers as the key metric and 7 are unverified, and 15 have a scale tier of "?". 12 are owned by an "Individual."
- They still head toward royalties. 14 of the 17 carry the "Licensing Royalties" tag. Mangom reported 700K fans (2026-01) and an Olive Young collab of 119 items, and Molang expanded through the rights agency Millimages to ~80 licensees and airing in 150+ countries (△). Both keep revenue undisclosed.
- The creator's share does not show. Handing rights to an agency can grow the licensee count, but the map does not say how much of that reaches the creator. Fan counts cannot be read as income.
25 players declining or exited
- Nearly half of the shrinking side is IP owners. 16 players are "Declining" and 9 are "Exited / Sold," and among them 11 are IP owners and studios and 6 are manufacturers and licensees.
- Korean toy IP shrank together. Young Toys posted 2025 consolidated revenue of KRW 45.29B (−8.8%) and entered a debt workout on 2026-04-13 (reported), and Choirock Holdings' operating loss widened to KRW 5.56B (✔).
- Even big IP gets written down. Rovio's last standalone revenue was €317.7M (2022), and Sega booked a 2025 goodwill impairment of ¥31.4B. Disney's direct stores fell from ~307 in 2020 to ~63 in FY25.
Five questions to ask before a character licensing deal
- Is the royalty on wholesale or retail? As 9% and 5.4% show, the number changes with the denominator.
- Is there a minimum guarantee? Check whether something is paid even if sales are small, or royalties only start after a threshold.
- Who carries inventory and production? The licensor's high margins come from licensees carrying the inventory.
- If an agency is involved, what is the creator's share? The licensee count and the creator's income are different numbers.
- Where do the rights stay? If the rights are handed over, the creator may not share in it even as the IP grows.
How to read the numbers
- Verification marks: among the key metrics for 196 players, 50 are ✔ (filing or primary source), 120 are △ (press or estimate) and 10 are ◇, and 16 carry no mark (—). ◇ marks values not yet checked against the source, so it is safest to read it as the weakest basis. Most of the 10 ◇ rows have no figure at all; the ones with a figure are Primark and Capcom.
- Read tiers together with metric types. Use the "Metric Type" filter to separate the 18 licensed retail sales rows from the 83 company revenue rows. Within one tier, what others sold and what a company booked are different money. Scale Tier "?" covers 87 players, where revenue could not be verified or only follower or cumulative figures exist.
- Some numbers should not be subtracted or divided. Global retail sales of $389.8B and the $338.3B participating total in Top Global Licensors come from different surveys. The roughly $21.0B in royalties received by brand owners (2025 est.) is an in-house calculation applying 5.4%, not an official figure.
- Read the map's own "Retailers & Licensors Out-Earn Makers" with care. Daiso's operating profit of ₩442.4B is larger than Iconix's ₩12.7B, but Daiso's character share is undisclosed. This is not a comparison of money earned from characters.
- Our own counts and the blanks. Player counts are our tally of the map data by each player's main role. A tag means that revenue source exists, not its share. 87 players have a scale tier of "?", so the patterns above come from the few companies whose books are visible, not from an industry average.
The 5.4% reads less as a sign that owners are weak than as the price of handing inventory and factory risk to someone else. And for most indie creators on the map, even that share does not yet show up as a number.