Behind VPN rankings, 40–100% commissions
We counted all 262 entries on the VPN map. Only 17 of the 97 consumer-side entries publish an independent audit, and 15 of the 24 free apps hide who owns them. This piece follows what "Best VPN" rankings do not answer.
Behind VPN rankings, 40–100% commissions
about 4 min
The first thing many people meet when choosing a VPN is a "Best VPN" ranking. But the outlets doing the ranking are on this map too, under Type ⑪, "Review · Affiliate · White-Label Infra." This piece does not say which VPN is better. It asks how money flows behind the ranking table and what a ranking cannot tell you. It reads the map's 262 entries as of October 13, 2026.
This time we did not pick standout cases. We counted the whole map by type, audit field, ownership field and headline figure, and three things came out. Of the 97 entries in the consumer-facing types ①–⑥, 17 publish an independent audit. Of the 24 free and ad-supported apps, 15 have ownership marked "Opaque / Hidden." And of the 38 entries that use revenue as their headline figure, 29 sit on the enterprise side (⑦ · ⑧), where companies pay.
40–100% of the first sale goes to the referrer
- Commission formats differ by brand. NordVPN pays 100% on a new 1-month plan, 40% on 6-month to 2-year plans and 30% on renewal. Surfshark pays 40% on new sales (45%+ by volume). ExpressVPN pays a flat $13, $22 or $36 per sale with no renewal cut (△). What a referrer has reason to push first seems to vary by brand too.
- It interlocks with the discount structure. The standard pattern is "high monthly list price, 70–80% discount on 2-year prepaid plans, and renewal at full list price." NordVPN shows $12.99 a month against ~$3/mo on a 2-year plan (△). So check whether a ranking's price is the first payment or the renewal price.
- YouTube and podcasts run on the same axis. The map lists sponsorships by Nord, Surfshark and Express on the same line as affiliate revenue (△). A recommendation seen outside a review site may share the same money trail.
When the outlet's owner is a VPN company
- Review sites have been bought. Kape's vpnMentor was acquired for about $150M (2021 · press △). The map notes that it ranks parent brands ExpressVPN, CyberGhost and PIA at #1–#2, along with critical analysis that its review text has no mention of "Kape," only a small "Ownership" label (△).
- Disclosure and verification levels differ. Cybernews states the Nord founders' investment in its editorial policy. Comparitech is listed as affiliated with Hotspot Shield's parent (△). Safety Detectives' ownership ties are claimed only by competitor blogs and forums and remain unconfirmed in primary filings.
- The commission tag clusters in two places. The 15 entries tagged "Affiliate · Review Commission" are 10 consumer paid VPNs and 5 review outlets, and nothing else. The side that pays and the side that is paid sit in the same table.
- Statistics come from the same arena. GWI's global usage rate plateaued at 22.7–24.7% in 2022–2025 (△), while the map notes that many "explosive VPN growth" stats come from VPN vendors' own PR. Top10VPN, source of the UK +1,987% (vs. the daily average over the 28–30 days before the event), earns affiliate commissions, and Japan's 9% usage rate comes from a NordVPN survey (△).
Count the whole map and audits are rare
- 17 of the 97 consumer-side entries. In types ①–⑥, 17 entries have "Independent Audit Published" in the audit field, 50 are "Unconfirmed," 5 are "Breach / Incident" and 3 are "No Audit." The rest are rows such as protocols and underground markets, where an audit does not apply.
- Paid and free split apart. The 30 rows of ① Consumer Paid VPN show Independent Audit Published 11, Unconfirmed 9, No Audit 3, Breach / Incident 1 and N/A 6, while the 24 rows of ② Free · Ad-Supported VPN show no published audit, with Unconfirmed 20 and Breach / Incident 4.
- 4 of the 9 breach rows are not VPNs. Across the map, the 9 "Breach / Incident" rows are 4 free apps, 4 resale proxies and 1 paid VPN. The side that sells other people's connections ran into trouble as often as free apps did.
The owners of the 24 free apps are hard to see
- The ownership field is blank first. Of the 24 free and ad-supported apps in ②, 15 are "Opaque / Hidden," and none has a ✔ headline figure. 14 sit in a "Censorship State" jurisdiction. None of the 30 paid VPNs in ① is marked hidden.
- Top download slots share one cluster. The map groups 15 entries as the "Chinese-Owned App Cluster" flagged by TTP in 2025. Turbo VPN has '100M+' installs on Google Play, and X-VPN reports '150M+' cumulative downloads and US cumulative revenue of $10M+ (△). Turbo VPN remained on both Apple and Google stores in the 2025-06 spot check.
- Free can be paid for in data. Meta's Onavo Protect had 271K downloads in Australia alone, and after a 2023 Australian ruling that it was misleading, the fine came to A$20M (✔). Urban VPN Proxy was disclosed to have harvested full AI chat transcripts from v5.5.0 (2025-07) (Koi Security 2025-12 · △).
The side that sells connections is on the same map
- ⑩ has 17 proxy and resale entries. Of the 19 entries tagged "Data · Traffic Resale," 16 are this type and 3 are free VPN apps. It is a path by which an app user's connection becomes the product.
- One consent screen can turn a device into an exit. Bright SDK sits inside free apps, and once a user accepts, that device's connection is resold into a proxy pool. Include Security's 2026-06 analysis says the SDK turns smart TVs into exit nodes and that a single node can relay up to 200GB/month (△).
- The line with botnets blurs. 911 S5 sold "19M+" unique IPs from infected PCs as proxies, and its operator was arrested on 2024-05-24 (✔). IPIDEA-linked exit nodes were tied to 550+ threat groups, and Google seized domains in 2026-01 (△).
The money shows in the books on the enterprise side
- Headline figures differ from the start. Of the 59 enterprise entries in ⑦ · ⑧ · ⑨, 29 are public companies, and 29 of the 38 entries that use revenue as their headline figure are here. Among the 97 consumer-side entries, 6 use revenue as their headline figure.
- The scale gap is large. Zscaler reported FY2026 revenue of $3.35B and ARR of $3.771B, and Fortinet reported 2025 revenue of $6.80B (✔). The largest consumer VPN group, Kape, reported 2022 revenue of $623.5M (✔), then went private in 2023 and has published no annual financials since.
- Enterprise VPN is the shrinking part. Fortinet removed SSL VPN tunnel mode in FortiOS 7.6.3 (2025), and in 2024-01 the US CISA ordered all federal agencies to disconnect Ivanti Connect Secure. Company money reads as moving from VPN appliances to zero-trust subscriptions.
Many brands can mean one group
- Top slots may share one house. In ①–③ the map lists 7 Nord Security rows and 5 rows each for Kape and Gen Digital. Kape runs ExpressVPN, PIA and CyberGhost, and Nord runs NordVPN + Surfshark.
- Acquired brands can be folded. Atlas VPN shut down on 2024-04-24, and its paid users were moved to NordVPN. A brand that looked independent ended up inside the group's flagship.
- Even a tech giant folded. VPN by Google One shut down on 2024-06-20 because 'people simply weren't using it' (△). 8 of the 97 consumer-side entries are rows that closed or stopped.
Five questions to ask before choosing a VPN
- Who made this ranking? Check the outlet's ownership and investors first. The "Affiliate · Review Commission" tag is attached to the side that does the ranking too.
- Is this the first payment or the renewal price? A 2-year prepaid discount and the renewal list price are different numbers.
- When was the audit, and what did it cover? A published audit is a document from one point in time. 50 of the 97 consumer-side entries have "Unconfirmed" in the audit field.
- Who owns this app? 15 of the 24 free apps have ownership marked "Opaque / Hidden."
- If it is free, what pays for it? Check whether it is ads, data collection or resale of your connection.
How to read the numbers
- Verification marks. ✔ = filing or primary source, △ = press or estimate, ✘ = common claim that is wrong. Of the 262 entries, 64 have a ✔ headline figure and, apart from 1 ✘, the rest are △. The price and commission table is also mostly △. Proton VPN's official page gives no % (✔), while directories cite 40%–100% (△).
- Separate structure from proof. The map shows a structure of commissions and ownership. It does not prove that any single ranking was ordered by commission. Its own wording is that review rankings "easily mirror commission rankings."
- A published audit does not mean no incidents. NordVPN, an audit-published row, also records unauthorized access to 1 server in 2018-03 that was disclosed only on 2019-10-21, and PureVPN records providing connection logs in 2017 (△). Conversely, a Greek criminal case against Windscribe was dismissed in 2025-04 after it showed no logs existed.
- Tallies count rows. They count product and company rows as they stand, not companies, and ① also includes AI tool rows. A tag means that revenue source exists, not its share.
- Do not mix user numbers. NordVPN's "15M+" covers all of Nord Security (△), and Kape's roughly 7.4M paid subscribers are as of 2022-12-31 (✔). Metric types and dates differ, so they cannot be compared directly.
- Our own counts and the blanks. 103 entries have a scale tier of "?". A tier is a rough grade from one headline figure, not a quality ranking. The patterns above come from the few companies whose books are visible, not from an industry average.
VPN rankings compare speed and price, but who earns money from the ranking and who owns the app only show when you ask separately. And most consumer VPNs on the map have not yet published an independent audit.